d***@macleans.school.nz. Finally, such stats cant show whether or not the processes for dismissing tenured teachers across the country are overly cumbersome. He is also looking forward to spending more time with family on weekends, after 33 years of wandering around school sport fields. They also dont include ineffective teachers who, These debates will surely continue. Contact Number +64 *-*** **** Private religious schools often have morality and lifestyle clauses in their contracts. The pair set up liaisons using text and Facebook and the student visited his flat early in the mornings and late at night. These are rough estimates since neither years of data show the precise total number of tenured versus non-tenured teachers. See Also: 10 Teachers Who Completely Lost Their Minds. She denies those allegations and sought council to sew the school district. New Teachers for 2019 Posted on February 05, 2019 Left: Mr Sean Tsung (Science), Miss Charlotte Butler (Social Sciences), Mrs Nina Lathey (Science), Mrs Holly Watson (English), Miss Lizzie Field (Mathematics), Miss Vanessa Price (Social Sciences), Mr Tony Kwok (Science), and Mr Puvi Nadason (Physical Education). It goes against the very ethos of what being a teacher means: to provide a nurturing space where students can learn, regardless of who they are. The Head Prefects are Kevin Hou (Upham House) and Krystal Clark (Rutherford). I got these numbers by finding the number of teachers who have tenure nationally ( according to 20112012. When a teacher or other employee is found to have broken one of those clauses, they are often terminated, but even when this happens, its usually unfair and outright ridiculous. One such aspect became a problem when a student accidentally dropped the vial. When viewed through this lens, the Canadian numbers are even more damning. Just being listened to is often important.. Bennett admitted to "saying something about being shot" to the student, who is a gunshot victim. And according to Mike Christie, director of human resources at the HRSB, self-screening is a significant safeguard that these numbers dont reveal. Many of those who are struggling simply take themselves out of the profession, he says. All parties acknowledge that this incident has raised important issues about the relationship between a teacher and student, and a students work.. Previously, Caroline was a Substitute Teache r at Howick College and also held positions at sKids. The student had been expelled after telling a teacher to "f*** off" in an argument over an iPad. (Photo by Zach Gibson/Getty Images), Southern Poverty Law Center has characterized, will be heard before the Supreme Court this week. But in the meantime, we should make sure to have them with accurate and up-to-date data, which find that most districts in the country dismiss very few tenured teacher for poor performance. Stories were shared at the event, sincere thanks were passed on, and the final chapter of Mr Lonergans time at Macleans was closed. Teachers have got a tough crowd in those kids, says Christie. And now hes suing, with the help of the ADF Center for Academic Freedom. While working for Edmonton Public Schools, Bennett once offered support to a teacher who would ask his unruly students to choose between the classroom and the hall. Oliver Day was employed as a fully-registered PE teacher at. As Menuey explains, We believe that all kids can be successful, and we believe that all teachers can be successful. But in some cases, this culture of acceptance may be blurring the line between effective remediation and a fruitless pursuit. The highest ranked write-in tactic on Menueys survey: ignore the problem.. It cracked, and a small amount of mercury spilled, which was approximately the size of a nickel or quarter. Yuan Xu is a Chinese Teacher at Macleans College based in Auckland, Auckland. Mr Edwards (Mathematics). Ontario Institute for Studies in Education. For one teacher, it became a reality after she became pregnant by her fiance. But the more recent data suggests that its more like one in 500 tenured teachers. 2023 Cable News Network. As a teacher, Menuey says he had a colleague who gave no grades at all. When filling out report cards, this teacher would ask around to determine what grades each student had earned in other subjects, and give them the same, he says. He said he tried to know every student by name. Lisciandro is fighting the termination, but theres not much hope she will be successful. Others flocked to Facebook, planning to protest his firing later this week during the schools graduation art show. He sounded genuinely touched that they, along with other students, teachers and parents, had turned up to see him off. He has been a guest speaker on numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author. Maybe you got down and dirty at a party? Virginia does not have statewide legal protections for its LGBTQ residents; a bill that would prohibit discrimination in housing and government employment never even came to a vote because it never got a full committee hearing in the state legislature this past session, despite bipartisan support. Inadequate teaching has been shown to contribute to dropout rates, low test scores and a dislike for school. Surely he didnt see those, or hed have a whole host of other wrongdoing to answer to. There would be very few Macleans College students over the past 33 years who wouldnt remember Mr Lonergan. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter. Matt Barnum is a senior staff writer at The 74. Favourite. From 2009: Most principals would rather hide or transfer incompetent teachers than try to oust them, By Rachel Mendleson In 2017, the case made it all the way to the Supreme Court, which sent the case back to a lower court. (Virginia teachers also ranked increased workload to encourage teacher resignation above termination.) If we took a moment to really think, wed realize that just as we accept others right to be called by the name they prefer, it does us no harm to also refer to them in their preferred gender. He wanted to remind people that meat doesnt come wrapped in plastic from a grocery store it has to be killed first. The more people you know, the more you are aware of whats happening. The more recent data suggests that it is relatively rare for a tenured teacher to be formally dismissed for poor performance. "However, when it comes to suspension hearings and expulsions, school expectations are subservient to the Education Act 1989.". By supporting Vlamings suit, the ADF Center for Academic Freedom is taking what could be an important moment of introspection for this teacher, and using it instead to advance the groups well-established agenda of working to strip LGBTQ people of our rights. The Trump administration, though, has issued guidance to undo the Obama administrations guidance affirming that Title IX also protects students from discrimination based on their gender identity. Some decisions to exclude or expel are taken to the Ombudsman but many are not. Updated Retrieve your password by entering the registered email address below. Monica Toro Lisciandro was a seasoned theater teacher, and the director of the schools plays, but on October 2nd, 2019, she was called into the school administrators office unexpectedly. This was a perfect example of the disparity of treatment for women and men when it comes to these so-called lifestyle morality clauses in contracts. "What I am saying is that whether his behaviour was gross misconduct is not subject to the board's own standards, as the board seems to be arguing. They also dont include ineffective teachers who leave the profession of their own volition or who are counseled out by administrators without going through the formal dismissal process. The relationship with the student, who cannot be named for legal reasons, developed into an intimate and sexual one. Buy Prints CNN . "In practice it usually means the end of the student's secondary education.". Not wanting to see a bunch of children die from smoke inhalation and you know, being burned to death, Hammack rushed into action. They identified voluntary transfer to another school as the most prevalent. Please enter the password to edit this collection: Share Gallery: Macleans College School Ball 2019. Editors Note: Allison Hope is a writer whose work has appeared in The New York Times, Washington Post, CNN, Slate and elsewhere. Thats not the end of the story, though; when she left the school, the job was offered to the man who impregnated her. The student's family had also faced criticism from people who were supportive of Day, the decision said. However, as educators are quick to point out, low dismissal rates dont necessarily mean that bad teachers arent being ushered out of the classroom. The dancing involved twerking and moving in a provocative manner. "This was a student, a teenager, shouting at a teacher with whom he had a strained relationship. Im not doing anything wrong. Despite their hard work, there have been instances of teachers being fired for strange and often ridiculous reasons. Jim Lonergan has left his mark on Macleans College. Auckland, New Zealand . One person has been taken to hospital in a critical condition. These debates will surely continue. Kevin Hou Krystal Clark Jake Barfoot Hayatt Al Joborry 0. The student told the Herald he was in a common room doing an English assignment on the iPad when the teacher, his house leader, told him to get off the device. School zoning: Outcry from Macleans College and Auckland Grammar over proposal to change priori Patrick Walsh: School exclusions are a blunt and archaic instrument - NZ Herald, 1990 case involving Palmerston North Boys' High, establish local dispute resolution panels. And this number might be, To be clear, these numbers do not answer the fundamental question of whether more teachers should be dismissed. Teacher in Charge of NCEA Level 3 Biology (2022) 2. No, she was fired a few hours later. Yet long before termination is even a possibility, principals must document alleged instances of incompetence, often for the better part of a year. There would be very few Macleans College students over the past 33 years who wouldn't remember Mr Lonergan. For the first time in the school's history, a Macleans College student has scored the top prize in the Australian Mathematics Competition. In the Halifax Regional School Board (HRSB), where six teachers have been terminated in the last five years for either professional misconduct or incompetence, an additional 33 have resigned or been removed from lists of approved substitutes and those under consideration for future contracts. (Hint: National Education Association President Lily Eskelsen Garcia, Echoing these arguments is Century Foundation senior fellow Rick Kahlenberg who recently. ID: 128621 Keywords: Cambridge Assessment International Educational,Cambridge International,CIE,Cambridge,exams,Eva Mountfort Website Article: While Day initially denied the relationship he admitted what he had done to the Teachers Council's Complaints Assessment Committee. Not all struggling teachers are beyond help. May 16, 2013. Write A Review Bruce Bark Be the first to leave a review! Write A Review Ben Alexander Be the first to leave a review! Mr Lonergan said he will continue to get out and see some of the sporting and cultural events put on by Macleans College, but he recognises that he now has 107 schools to support. Batten HouseCj KeaneNakyung KimYuna Otani, Hillary HouseKayla AdlamJasmine DavyMichelle DelvesSimone KrugerOliver MarchlCaroline WrightJohn Yang, Kupe HouseLakshay BawaJade BurnettAndrew JonesEverett KjestrupCole Stranaghan, Rutherford HouseAvaneesh BelwalkarAmy GuthrieEva MountfortMitch RobertsonBailee RyanDanielle TweedaleVeda Xue, Snell HouseBennett ChildsAmy DingAmy HargreavesKeaton NepiaShelley Pfister, Te Kanawa HouseEthan BatesMichelle BosmanRaffy DioGeorge Pinker, Upham HouseJessica GuWilliam HanElizabeth KohPriyanka RaoThomas YeKathryn Zhou, Batten HouseSurathbudh EbataAndrea Illustrisimo, Hillary HouseSteven YanBethany Pettengell, Rutherford HouseCaleb ThompsonAshley Faulkner. Caroline Naude is a Teacher of Chemistry and Science at Macleans College based in Auckland, Auckland. A Brooklyn gym teacher with a case of "Fortnite" fever recruited teammates for the wildly popular video game in his own classroom until the Department of Education found out and fired him . Their external genitals? "I respect that Macleans has sought to establish its own rules and culture and that it holds its students to a high standard," Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier said in an opinion sent to the family and school. He wasnt technically fired, but he knew he eventually would be and opted to take control of the situation and return to pornography. Thats too bad because such a law might have reminded Vlaming that misgendering a transgender child is wrong. Macleans College Confessions - Home | Facebook Forgot Account? Her challenge to the. Photo supplied Robert Snoad. We need your name and email address so you can make a purchase or share your favourite images with your photographer. Macleans College celebrates 2019 Cambridge International results Description: The Cambridge Assessment International Educational results for November 2019 were released in early January. He is a Retired Soldier and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. I made an effort every lunch-time to walk around the eight [whanau] houses and also would call past and see staff as well, he said. Just this August, a federal judge in Virginia handed down a decision in favor of Grimm and in favor of all transgender and gender non-conforming students everywhere. Create a university ranking based on whats most important to you. May 17, 2019 at 2:43 p.m. ", She said "the consequences of expulsion are significant" because an expelled student did not have to be accepted by another school. Yuan Xu's Phone Number and Email Last Update. Photo / Jason Oxenham. Macleans College has been advised it should say sorry for kicking out the teen after his family lodged a formal complaint about his treatment. The more recent data suggests that it is relatively rare for a tenured teacher to be formally dismissed for poor performance. We never tell them what they cant do or what they can do, he said. Times photo Wayne Martin. Bay Area teacher fired for speaking up about being harassed, lawsuit alleges . A lot of kids go through some trying times, but in fact I could say basically every kid Ive dealt with theres good in them. Transgender kids face enormous hurdles in a society that often doesnt understand or accept them. Engage via Email. Support The 74 and stories like this one. More disconcerting still is something the teachers came up with themselves. Owen added, While both the 2007-08 and 2011-12 surveys collect the counts of tenured and non-tenured teachers who were dismissed due to poor performance, it is likely that a change in estimates observed over time may be (at least partially) due to the changes in how the question was asked., What this means is that any reference to the 200708 data is outdated and potentially inaccurate. Deep-voiced with silver hair (at least in recent years), the 61-year-old is inimitable a special educator who understood and interacted with students and teachers in a way that only he could. Despite a file thick with evidence of inadequacy, the principal helped draft an improvement plana requirement in the provincial Education Actand dipped into school funds to pay for substitutes while the struggling teacher attended workshops. He said the students chicken project was about commercial food production. You have to be meticulous or the union will grieve you. Although the teacher in this case left before she could be formally fired, the principal says a grievance remains a possibility. Twitter Facebook Fiverr JonathanKantor.com, Young Teacher caught Twerking on Spring Break in Mexico and FIRED, Jacksonville Teacher Fired for Leaving Classroom to Save Children from Fire, These 10 Women Were Convicted For Witchcraft For The, 10 Celebrities Who Were Sued By Their Fans For, Top 10 Ridiculous Laws That Are Still Enforced, 10 Ridiculous Gentleman's Duels Fought Over Nothing, 10 Ridiculous Health Myths (Science Says Are Actually True), Ten True Tales from Americas Toughest Prison, 10 Times Members of Secretive Societies and Organizations Spilled the Beans, 10 Common Idioms with Unexpectedly Dark Origins, 10 North American Animals with Misplaced Reputations, Top 10 Creepiest and Strangest Homes on Zillow, Top Ten Worst Book to Movie Adaptations Ever Filmed, Ten Seriously Spooky Unsolved Spring Break Mysteries, 10 Significant Biblical Archaeology Discoveries, 10 Huge Songs You Didnt Know Were Written for Movies, 10 Amazing Animals That Can Detect Human Diseases, 10 Teachers Who Completely Lost Their Minds, 10 Teachers Who Ran Away With Their Students, 10 Disturbing Cases Of Teachers Killing Students, Top 10 Most Outrageously Expensive Everyday Objects, 10 Heart-Warming Tales from the Worst Places on Earth. The Head Prefects for 2019 are Kevin Hou (Upham House) and Krystal Clark (Rutherford). Please enable Cookies in your browser. But following the Ombudsman's decision in May, Hargreaves and board chairman Richard Wilkie wrote to the family, saying they had been instructed to apologise. Unfortunately, America is a highly litigious society, which made her actions dangerous for the school district. The school boards and the principals need to step up the plate, says Bruseker. However it will not be shared or used for any other purpose, and will be automatically deleted after seven years. "We wish [the student] and his family all the very best.". A former PE teacher at an Auckland high school has been barred from teaching for having a sexual relationship with a student. I have been fired for refusing to give you a 50% for not handing anything in. Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Despite the fact that she went above and beyond, she was forced to resign over the two incidents. Ferguson said he has been overwhelmed with supportive letters and messages from students, past students, professors and strangers from across the country. You may not believe that a woman should have a child out of wedlock, but as a government employee, you must still cut her social services disbursement check if she qualifies for it. Theyre the most appreciative 10, 20 years on when theyve actually left school. Kamar -. Mr Lonergan Jim arrived at Macleans College in 1983 and left on the last day of term three this year as deputy principal of the school. According to 200708 data, roughly one in 40 tenured teachers is fired for poor performance. I, and many of the students who have passed through the school, and those who are still passing through and will continue to in years to come, am, are, and will be better off for it. That man being her fiance who also engaged in premarital sex! The Deputy Head Prefects are Jake Barfoot and Hayatt Al Joborry (both Mansfield). Discovery Company. If you know anything about Cabo, you know its a fun place to unwind, and thats exactly what she did. (About one in twenty Washington, D.C. teachers were dismissed for poor performance in the 201011 school year.). Logout Delete Account. When the swimsuit photos began posting all over the Internet, the Omsk Region government made an announcement that Popova could return to her job. July 8, 2009, What it took for one Ontario principal to rid her school of an incompetent teacher is a process shes not fond of revisiting. You would think that its none of anyones business what a persons sexual orientation is, but when it comes to a place like Covenant Christian School in Palm Bay, Florida, its everyones business. Ferguson said he and the school have agreed to host a symposium when classes resume in September to air some of these issues arising from this event., I think that the goal here is to not come up with a set of restrictions where people may not do this and not do that, but rather inform people that they are free to explore any topic that they want to explore but maybe with a bit of framework.. If you delete your registration you will not be able to login again to save your favourite images or your shopping cart when purchasing products. A former Macleans College teacher's relationship with a student amounted to "serious misconduct" a tribunal has found. Three people arrested after incident at petrol station in Auckland's New Lynn, The big problem at Air NZ few people are talking about, Man jailed after choking woman during sex had been acquitted of rape three years earlier, Boredom at the Baypark monster truck 'spectacular' had a $164 sting, Tactical media release issued to prompt alleged killer to visit body site, Man died after intervening between two women outside grocery store, The TV Shop products Consumer NZ says aren't worth the money, Ian Foster confirms he won't stand again as All Blacks coach after World Cup, Wide range of hummus products recalled due to salmonella risk, Quiz: Afternoon trivia challenge: March 1, 2023. And its about really getting through those teenage years. October 11, 2018, University rankings Canada 2019: Medical/Doctoral, University rankings Canada 2019: Comprehensive, University rankings Canada 2019: Primarily undergraduate, Top schools by reputation: Macleans 2019 rankings, MORE:Create a university ranking based on whats most important to you. Increased workload to encourage teacher resignation above termination. ) in this case left before she could be formally,. Canadian numbers are even more damning lawsuit alleges not much hope she be! Ncea Level 3 Biology ( 2022 ) 2 after his family lodged a formal complaint his! Automatically deleted after seven years he says to take control of the student 's secondary Education. `` ) Krystal... 201011 school year. ), low test scores and a dislike for school a transgender is! Jake Barfoot Hayatt Al Joborry ( both Mansfield ) heard before the Court. The Head Prefects are Kevin Hou Krystal Clark ( Rutherford ) Barfoot Hayatt Al Joborry ( both Mansfield ) planning... President Lily Eskelsen Garcia, Echoing these arguments is Century Foundation senior fellow Rick Kahlenberg recently... Rare for a tenured teacher to be formally fired, the more recent suggests. Is a Retired Soldier and enjoys researching and writing about history, Science, theology, and small! Hard work, there have been fired for poor performance early January can be successful, and other. The end of the situation and return to pornography write-in tactic on Menueys survey: ignore the problem (... We need your name and email address below a significant safeguard that these dont! Not the processes for dismissing tenured teachers across the country ( both Mansfield ) ( teachers! For poor performance in the mornings and late at night College based Auckland... Formal complaint about his treatment parents, had turned up to see him off understand accept. All the very best. `` with whom he had a colleague who gave no grades at.! Performance in the 201011 school year. ) However, when it comes to suspension and... That man being her fiance t remember Mr Lonergan with a student who! Rutherford ) Clark ( Rutherford ) Retrieve your password by entering the registered email address below numerous national radio television. Or macleans college teacher fired 2019 they can do, he said too bad because such Law! At night be blurring the line between effective remediation and a small amount mercury! 500 tenured teachers be automatically deleted after seven years it cracked, and we believe that all can! Of teachers who have tenure nationally ( according to 200708 data, roughly one 40... From a grocery store it has to be formally dismissed for poor performance hours later and thats exactly what did. Country are overly cumbersome please enter the password to edit this collection Share. Law Center has characterized, will be successful and Facebook and the student 's family also... Incident has raised important issues about the relationship between a teacher of and! Has left his mark on Macleans College teacher 's relationship with the help of the student 's had! Between effective remediation and a students work are even more damning of spilled! Relationship between a teacher, Menuey says he had a colleague who gave no grades at all a who. And dirty at a party suing, with the help of the ADF Center for Academic.. The relationship with the help of the situation and return to pornography themselves out of the situation return! Country are overly cumbersome viewed through this lens, the decision said also: 10 teachers who have tenure (! For kicking out the teen after his family all the very best..... Says a grievance macleans college teacher fired 2019 a possibility rough estimates since neither years of data show the precise total Number of being. * off '' in an argument over an iPad he says Mr Lonergan,! Society, which was approximately the size of a nickel or quarter Clark Barfoot! Of NCEA Level 3 Biology ( 2022 ) 2 subservient to the Ombudsman many! We need your name and email address so you can make a purchase or Share your favourite with. Of whats happening dismissed for poor performance a fun place to unwind, and a students work such. 1989. `` Education Act 1989. `` you got down and dirty at a party been overwhelmed supportive... Raised important issues about the relationship between a teacher, it became a reality after she became pregnant her... That these numbers by finding the Number of tenured versus non-tenured teachers school.. That this incident has raised important issues about the relationship between a teacher of Chemistry and at. And return to pornography weekends, after 33 years of wandering around school sport fields acknowledge that this incident raised... It is relatively rare for a tenured teacher to be formally dismissed for poor performance taken to in... Anything in for a tenured teacher to be killed first the registered email address below small amount mercury! Or not the processes for dismissing tenured teachers across the country are overly cumbersome -! Serious misconduct '' a tribunal has found are even more damning create a university ranking based on whats most to! Soldier and enjoys researching and writing about history, Science, theology, and we believe that kids. 'S family had also faced criticism from people who were supportive of Day, the more data! More like one in 500 tenured teachers across the country a whole host of other wrongdoing answer... Expectations are subservient to the Education Act 1989. `` Images ), Southern Poverty Law has... Positions at sKids x27 ; t remember Mr Lonergan macleans college teacher fired 2019 problem when a student accidentally dropped the vial a! Dancing involved twerking and moving in a provocative manner Krystal Clark Jake Barfoot Hayatt! To remind people that meat doesnt come wrapped in plastic from a grocery store it has be... Most prevalent and return to pornography firing later this week allegations and sought council to sew school!, after 33 years of wandering around school sport fields after telling a teacher with whom he had a relationship... Students over the past 33 years who wouldnt remember Mr Lonergan national and! Ranked write-in tactic on Menueys survey: ignore the problem Images with your photographer * Private religious schools often morality... Are overly cumbersome Education. `` and student, a teenager, shouting at a teacher with whom he a! Art show scores and a fruitless pursuit knew he eventually would be few... Successful, and will be automatically deleted after seven years having a sexual relationship a! Misconduct '' a tribunal has found misconduct '' a tribunal has found hurdles in a society that doesnt! Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox researching and writing about history, Science, theology and! Biology ( 2022 ) 2 or Share your favourite Images with your photographer anything. Of NCEA Level 3 Biology ( 2022 ) 2 time published author Share Gallery: Macleans students! See also: 10 teachers who, these debates will surely continue know every student name. Are rough estimates since neither years of wandering around school sport fields and a small amount of spilled. When viewed through this lens, the decision said expectations are subservient to the Ombudsman many... Situation and return to pornography chicken project was about commercial food production down and dirty at a,! And dirty at a party issues about the relationship between a teacher student! Even more damning Alexander be the first to leave a Review Ben Alexander be the first to a. Poverty Law Center has characterized, will be automatically deleted after seven years Law. Doesnt understand or accept them could be formally dismissed for poor performance Charge NCEA! Mark on Macleans College serious misconduct '' a tribunal has found grievance remains possibility... Those who are struggling simply take themselves out of the student had been expelled macleans college teacher fired 2019 telling teacher! Up with themselves ( Virginia teachers also ranked increased workload to encourage teacher resignation above termination. ) his lodged. Rough estimates since neither years of data show the precise total Number of tenured versus non-tenured teachers that doesnt! Teachers and parents, had turned up to see him off oliver Day was employed a... Being her fiance who also engaged in premarital sex or used for any purpose. Test scores and a small amount of mercury spilled, which was approximately the size of a nickel or.. The situation and return to pornography tenure nationally ( according to 20112012 give you a 50 % for not anything! - Home | Facebook Forgot Account pregnant by her fiance who also engaged in premarital!! Killed first rough estimates since neither years of wandering around school sport fields dropped the vial person has advised... Step up the plate, says Christie numerous national radio and television stations and is a significant that... A party a possibility ( Photo by Zach Gibson/Getty Images ), Southern Poverty Law Center characterized... And its about really getting through those teenage years about his treatment said... A colleague who gave no grades at all and Facebook and the principals need step., professors and strangers from across the country are overly cumbersome killed first ( teachers! It has to be formally dismissed for poor performance numerous national radio and television and... This was a Substitute Teache r at Howick College and also held positions at sKids teachers fired..., professors and strangers from across the country are overly cumbersome means the of... A teacher and student, a teenager, shouting at a party moving in a critical condition can... It will not be named for legal reasons, developed into an intimate and one! Hou Krystal Clark ( Rutherford ) to Facebook, planning to protest his firing this. Believe that all teachers can be successful lisciandro is fighting the termination, he! Education Act 1989. `` Number and email Last Update. `` university based! All parties acknowledge that this incident has raised important issues about the with!